The 5-foot-6 senior catcher had led the Midgets to a 25-2 record and a berth in the Class A state quarterfinals at the time of her selection. McNeilly produced a .500 batting average with nine doubles, five home runs, 49 runs scored and 47 runs batted in through 27 games. A two-time First Team All-State selection, she swiped nine bases and compiled a .547 on-base percentage and a .804 slugging percentage.
McNeilly has maintained a 3.96 GPA in the classroom. She has signed a national letter of intent to play softball on scholarship at Minnesota State University Moorhead this fall.
Vice president of the Dickinson High student body, McNeilly has volunteered locally as a youth softball umpire and youth basketball referee. She has also donated her time to multiple fundraising campaigns to benefit her community.