| AOY | POY | Name | Year | Sport | Position | School | City | State | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mike Seander | 2005-06 | Boys Baseball | RHP | St. Raphael Academy | Pawtucket | RI | |||
| Ryan Walfield | 2004-05 | Boys Baseball | P, OF | Spaulding HS | Rochester | NH | |||
| Vince Judd | 1985-86 | Boys Baseball | 1B | Pittsburg | Pittsburg | NH | |||
| Michael Restovich | 1996-97 | Boys Baseball | P, 3B, C | Mayo | Rochester | MN | |||
| Vern Paradie | 1989-90 | Boys Baseball | P, 3B | Edward Little | Auburn | ME | |||
| Jeremy Sowers | 2000-01 | Boys Baseball | LHP, OF | Ballard HS | Louisville | KY | |||
| Dylan Covey | 2009-10 | Boys Baseball | RHP/OF | Maranatha HS | Pasadena | CA | |||
| Press Release | |||||||||
| Aaron Smith | 1993-94 | Boys Baseball | P, OF | Capital | Boise | ID | |||
| Derek Dietrich | 2006-07 | Boys Baseball | SS | St. Ignatius High | Cleveland | OH | |||
| Ricky Kimball | 1986-87 | Boys Baseball | P | Redan | Stone Mountain | GA | |||
| Sean Burroughs | 1997-98 | Boys Baseball | 3B | Woodrow Wilson | Long Beach | CA | |||
| John Roberts | 1990-91 | Boys Baseball | CF | Watson Chapel | Pine Bluff | AR | |||
| Thomas Baker | 2001-02 | Boys Baseball | RHP, OF | Holtville | Wetumpka | AL | |||
| Marcus Stroman | 2008-09 | Boys Baseball | P, SS | Patchogue-Medford HS | Medford | NY | |||
| John Patterson | 1995-96 | Boys Baseball | P | West Orange Stark | Orange | TX | |||
| Zac Fuesser | 2007-08 | Boys Baseball | LHP/OF | York Comprehensive HS | York | SC | |||
| Mark Gibbs | 1995-96 | Boys Baseball | SS | St. John's College | Washington | DC | |||
| John Burke | 1988-89 | Boys Baseball | P | Cherry Creek | Englewood | CO | |||
| Brian Montalbo | 1999-00 | Boys Baseball | RHP, SS | Dimond | Anchorage | AK | |||
| Dylan Bundy | 2009-10 | Boys Baseball | RHP/INF | Owasso HS | Owasso | OK | |||
| Press Release | |||||||||
| Geoff Shufelt | 1993-94 | Boys Baseball | P | St. Johnsbury Academy | St. Johnsbury | VT | |||
| Josh Donaldson | 2003-04 | Boys Baseball | SS, P | Faith Academy | Mobile | AL | |||
| Evan Anundsen | 2005-06 | Boys Baseball | RHP, DH | Columbine High School | Littleton | CO | |||
| Troy Hymes | 1986-87 | Boys Baseball | OF, P | Alta | Sandy | UT | |||
