| AOY | POY | Name | Year | Sport | Position | School | City | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Darrian Miller | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Blue Springs HS | Blue Springs | MO | ||
| Dylan Favre | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB/DB/P | St. Stanislaus College | Bay St. Louis | MS | ||
| Matt Miller | 2009-10 | Boys Football | WR | Capital HS | Helena | MT | ||
| Christian LeMay | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Butler HS | Matthews | NC | ||
| Esley Thorton | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Bismarck HS | Bismarck | ND | ||
| Bronson Marsh | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Millard South HS | Omaha | NE | ||
| Max Jacques | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Salem HS | Salem | NH | ||
| Tony Jones | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Don Bosco Preparatory School | Ramsey | NJ | ||
| Ronnie Daniels | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | La Cueva HS | Albuquerque | NM | ||
| Dezerick Reed | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB/LB | Del Sol HS | Las Vegas | NV | ||
| Dan Scalo | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Monroe-Woodbury HS | Central Valley | NY | ||
| Jordan Hicks | 2009-10 | Boys Football | LB/RB | Lakota West HS | West Chester | OH | ||
| Demarco Cobbs | 2009-10 | Boys Football | ATH | Central HS | Tulsa | OK | ||
| Jordan Johnson | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB/DB | Sheldon HS | Eugene | OR | ||
| Kyle Smith | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Lancaster Catholic HS | Lancaster | PA | ||
| Mike Read | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB/DB | Barrington HS | Barrington | RI | ||
| Marcus Lattimore | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Byrnes HS | Duncan | SC | ||
| Austin Sumner | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Brandon Valley HS | Brandon | SD | ||
| JaRon Toney | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB/LB | Alcoa HS | Alcoa | TN | ||
| Scotty Young | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Billy Ryan HS | Denton | TX | ||
| Harvey Langi | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Bingham HS | South Jordan | UT | ||
| Phillip Sims | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Oscar Smith HS | Chesapeake | VA | ||
| Max Librizzi | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Essex HS | Essex Junction | VT | ||
| Jake Heaps | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Skyline HS | Sammamish | WA |
