| AOY | POY | Name | Year | Sport | Position | School | City | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Justin Kauffman | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB/LB | West Anchorage HS | Anchorage | AK | ||
| Coty Blanchard | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Cherokee County HS | Centre | AL | ||
| Michael Dyer | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Little Rock Christian Academy | Little Rock | AR | ||
| Brett Hundley | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Chandler HS | Chandler | AZ | ||
 |
Malcolm Jones | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB/LB | Oaks Christian School | Westlake Village | CA | |
| Austin Hinder | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Steamboat Springs HS | Steamboat Springs | CO | ||
| Kevin Pierre-Louis | 2009-10 | Boys Football | LB/FB | King Low Heywood Thomas | Stamford | CT | ||
| Ricardo Young | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | HD Woodson HS | Washington | DC | ||
| C.J. Jones | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB/CB | A.I. du Pont HS | Wilmington | DE | ||
| Matt Elam | 2009-10 | Boys Football | LB/RB | William T. Dwyer HS | Palm Beach Gardens | FL | ||
| Hutson Mason | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Lassiter HS | Marietta | GA | ||
| Andrew Manley | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Leilehua HS | Wahiawa | HI | ||
| James Morris | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB/LB | Solon HS | Solon | IA | ||
| Taylor Kelly | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Eagle HS | Eagle | ID | ||
| Christian Lombard | 2009-10 | Boys Football | OL/DL | William Fremd HS | Palatine | IL | ||
| Kofi Hughes | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Cathedral HS | Indianapolis | IN | ||
| Blake Bell | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Bishop Carroll Catholic HS | Wichita | KS | ||
| Antonio Andrews | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Fort Campbell HS | Fort Campbell | KY | ||
| Kenny Hilliard | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Patterson HS | Patterson | LA | ||
| Nick LaSpada | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB/S | Billerica Memorial HS | Billerica | MA | ||
| Zach Zwinak | 2009-10 | Boys Football | FB/LB | Linganore HS | Ijamsville | MD | ||
| Jack Mallis | 2009-10 | Boys Football | RB | Windham HS | Windham | ME | ||
| Jason Fracassa | 2009-10 | Boys Football | QB | Stevenson HS | Sterling Heights | MI | ||
| A.J. Tarpley | 2009-10 | Boys Football | LB/TE | Wayzata HS | Plymouth | MN |
1 of 463 | Next